• About Kathy Shaidle
  • Kathy Shaidle: Donate
  • Kathy Shaidle: Privacy policy

5 Feet of Fury

Kathy Shaidle's blog. Est. 2000

Malcolm Gladwell’s ‘theory’ about Northern Ireland proves he’s a total twit

November 25, 2013 By Kathy Shaidle

I didn’t realize he was this bad, but wow.

And by the way, that “peace movement” favorite — Le Chambon, the French village that refused to hand over its Jews during WWII — isn’t all its cracked up to be:

In a throwaway passage, Gladwell tells us himself that the village was in fact being protected by a Gestapo official, who gave the mayor prior warning of raids, and by sympathetic elements in the local Vichy police. By 1943, when the episode occurred, the war on Germany’s eastern front was not going well, and there must have been many in the Gestapo and the Vichy regime who suspected that the tide was turning against them. So this is not just a story of altruism and the impotence of villains. But for Gladwell these complicating facts are irrelevant. What the episode shows, he concludes, is that “wiping out a town or a people or a movement is never as simple as it looks. The powerful are not as powerful as they look—nor the weak as weak.” Determined to extract a consoling lesson, he passes over the perilous contingencies that shaped the actual course of events. Yet the people of the Czech village of Lidice, which was razed to the ground, its inhabitants executed or sent to concentration camps by the Nazis in 1942 in reprisal for the assassination of Reich Protector Reinhard Heydrich, were not so fortunate. (…)

Reading Gladwell’s blithe assurances about happy endings for the vulnerable, one is reminded of Martin Buber’s rejoinder to Gandhi, who had urged Jews in Germany to practice non-violence against the Third Reich of the sort he was using against the British in India. “A diabolic universal steam-roller,” Buber explained, “cannot thus be withstood.” Earlier in the letter, Buber asked Gandhi: “Do you know or do you not know, Mahatma, what a concentration camp is like and what goes on there? Do you know of the torments of the concentration camp, of its methods of slow and quick slaughter?” The Mahatma did not want to know. It seems that many of Gladwell’s readers, in their less extreme circumstances, adopt a similar attitude toward the world. Unwilling to confront the raw facts of power, they prefer to inhabit a fantasy world in which it can be cleverly conjured away.

This guy at Esquire is equally fed up.

More from my site

  • Another famous old feminist finally acknowledges the truthAnother famous old feminist finally acknowledges the truth
  • Calling the United Church of Canada ‘the country’s largest Protestant denomination’ is like calling Michael Jackson ‘the King of Pop’Calling the United Church of Canada ‘the country’s largest Protestant denomination’ is like calling Michael Jackson ‘the King of Pop’
  • Every word of this is true. And I don’t care. Sorry.Every word of this is true. And I don’t care. Sorry.
  • “‘Bigger Than Life’ (1956) has been reevaluated, and is considered by many to be Ray’s masterpiece”“‘Bigger Than Life’ (1956) has been reevaluated, and is considered by many to be Ray’s masterpiece”

Filed Under: conservative blog

« As opposed to the other non-stop stuff that turns them all into communists…
‘My Favorite Turkeys’: Box office failures that aren’t all bad »
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Archives

Copyright © 2023 · Magazine Pro Theme On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in