• About Kathy Shaidle
  • Kathy Shaidle: Privacy policy

5 Feet of Fury

Kathy Shaidle's blog. Est. 2000

The Timothy Leary of Antifa: I was going to mock Professor Mark Brey’s dumb comments about free speech and Weimar…

November 10, 2017 By Kathy Shaidle

…in that semi-viral Chronicle of Higher Education profile…

In fact, there’s a point Mr. Bray made in an interview that Mr. Scott often finds himself citing. “We don’t look back at the Weimar Republic today and celebrate them for allowing Nazis to have their free-speech rights,” he says. “We look back and say, Why didn’t they do something?”

by quoting Mark Steyn extensively.

But Steyn beat me to it, thank God.

Now I can just read and savour instead:

It is a testament to the wholesale moronization of our culture that there are gazillions of apparently sane people willing to take out six figures of debt they’ll be paying off for decades for the privilege of being “taught” by the likes of Professor Bray. The reason “we don’t look back at the Weimar Republic today and celebrate them for allowing Nazis to have their free-speech rights” is because they didn’t. A decade ago, as my battles with Canada’s “human rights” commissions were beginning, I lost count of the number of bien-pensants insisting that, while in theory we could permit hatemongers like Steyn to exercise their free-speech rights, next thing you know it would be jackboots on the 401. (…)

“That analysis sounds as if it ought to be right,” I replied. “But the problem with it is that the Weimar Republic—Germany for the 12 years before the Nazi party came to power—had its own version of Section 13 and equivalent laws. It was very much a kind of proto-Canada in its hate speech laws. The Nazi party had 200 prosecutions brought against it for anti-Semitic speech. At one point the state of Bavaria issued an order banning Hitler from giving public speeches.”

And a fat lot of good it all did.

That’s why “we don’t look back at the Weimar Republic”. If you’re rube enough to sign up for Professor Bray’s classes, here’s more…

 

More from my site

  • Ed Anger says: ‘Pull the plug on newspapers!’Ed Anger says: ‘Pull the plug on newspapers!’
  • Chicago Transit Authority, Postal Service hires lots of ‘non-violent felons’Chicago Transit Authority, Postal Service hires lots of ‘non-violent felons’
  • Also? No money… ‘5 Horrifying Implications of the Star Trek Universe’Also? No money… ‘5 Horrifying Implications of the Star Trek Universe’
  • Exactly.Exactly.

Filed Under: Kathy Shaidle

« Some stuff I wrote about Louis CK a few years ago…
Jim Goad: Where Are All the Tranny Dudes In Politics? »

Archives

Copyright © 2023 · Magazine Pro Theme On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in