• About Kathy Shaidle
  • Kathy Shaidle: Donate
  • Kathy Shaidle: Privacy policy

5 Feet of Fury

Kathy Shaidle's blog. Est. 2000

“The influential historian Richard Hofstadter, fortified by the highly questionable social science of Theodor Adorno and others…”

August 18, 2017 By Kathy Shaidle

…saw authoritarian personalities and anti-intellectual tendencies bristling nearly everywhere in the America west of the Hudson River, tendencies that were the expression, not of a genuinely aggrieved outlook that deserved a hearing, but of social resentment (“status anxiety”) or even psychological disorder (“the paranoid style”).

This was too dismissive, and Hofstadter’s good friend, the great Southern historian C. Vann Woodward, took him to task for it. In a private letter, he lambasted Hofstadter for the sweepingly dismissive generalizations in his book Anti-Intellectualism in American Life, a work for which he would win a Pulitzer Prize and which is still widely cited as authoritative today:

“Dick, you just can’t do this,” Woodward exclaimed. “No amount of Adorno, Stouffer, Hartley, etc., will sustain it.” (…)

We ought to be wary when listening to any person or group that claims to speak for “the people.”

But we ought to listen.

Woodward’s tone, unlike Hofstadter’s, was wary but attentive, and not at all cynical. Remember, he hoped there would be more populistic rebellions in the future. And note well that his warning about democracy’s need for occasional “shock therapy” was offered in precisely the same spirit as Thomas Jefferson’s famous dictum that the well-being of a republic depends on periodic revolutions and rebellion. “What country can preserve its liberties,” Jefferson wrote from Paris in 1787, “if their rulers are not warned from time to time that their people preserve the spirit of resistance?” These are words that resonate in unexpected ways, given the time and place of their utterance.

More from my site

  • ‘Obama the race healer just another heel’‘Obama the race healer just another heel’
  • Michael Coren on Earth Day and environmentalismMichael Coren on Earth Day and environmentalism
  • Liberal blogger smears Ann Althouse as ‘anti-Semitic’Liberal blogger smears Ann Althouse as ‘anti-Semitic’
  • Dark Corners: The Alpha Incident (1978)Dark Corners: The Alpha Incident (1978)

Filed Under: Kathy Shaidle

« The Beach Boys: “An Arcadian theme in the California pastoral”
Mark Steyn: “It was his widow Priscilla who turned Elvis into a brand name” »
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Archives

Copyright © 2022 · Magazine Pro Theme On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in