5 Feet of Fury

In this sequel to last week’s column, Steve Sailer asks: What if Charles Murray is right about race and IQ?

Steve Sailer writes:

It is widely assumed by high-IQ whites that a scientific finding of a genetic contribution to the racial gaps in IQ would be catastrophically shattering to black self-esteem.

First, one thing to keep in mind is that there are about 7 million African-Americans with higher IQs than the average white American.

Second, back in the late 20th century, low self-esteem was seen as the magic bullet that explained all social ills. A couple of recent articles (one in New York magazine, one in The Guardian) have looked back on how the self-esteem craze was launched almost single-handedly by a California Democratic state legislator named John Vasconcelos.

Raising self-esteem as the panacea for all social problems was popular in part because it seemed to explain poor black performance: They simply lacked self-esteem.

But eventually it started to dawn upon researchers that low self-esteem could hardly explain black troubles, as seen in this headline in The Guardian in 2000:

Black teens score high in self-esteem: US study confounds anti-racism activists

In general, blacks seem to be pretty pleased with themselves for reasons that they find highly persuasive. Would this really change?