• About Kathy Shaidle
  • Kathy Shaidle: Donate
  • Kathy Shaidle: Privacy policy

5 Feet of Fury

Kathy Shaidle's blog. Est. 2000

So… we’re all agreed that Haitians are idiots, basically?

December 15, 2012 By Kathy Shaidle

I love it when critics prove the very point they object to, without even realizing it:

The case of Haiti provided the most egregious example. After a successful slave rebellion formally freed the Haitians from their French masters, the French still managed to bully the Haitians into paying them the huge indemnity for “lost property”—that is, freed slaves—in exchange for diplomatic relations.

By 1900, 80 percent of Haiti’s annual budget was consumed by these payments, which did not end until 1947. By then, Haiti had paid France about $21 billion in contemporary US dollars. In explaining Haiti’s social collapse, Diamond ignored 120 years of illegitimate debt payments as well as the long history of US interference in Haitian affairs, including America’s decades-long support of dictatorship under the Duvalier regime.

Diamond’s blindness to imperial power was of a piece with the assumption embedded in his subtitle: Failed societies (a reified abstraction) have somehow chosen to fail. In the wake of the earthquake that devastated Haiti in 2010, the New York Times columnist David Brooks revealed his attachment to the same point of view: Haitians’ attachment to voodoo and other primitive superstitions, Brooks believed, had immeasurably exacerbated their suffering in the wake of the disaster.

***
So we all agree that Haitians are idiots.

This guy just implies it — by insisting that Haitians are somehow blameless, easily duped victims, with as much human agency as pieces of driftwood, whose sinister pagan belief systems surely have NO impact on their day to day lives — while the very writers he objects to pretty much say it outright.

More from my site

  • The Drudge Paradox: My NEW Taki’s pieceThe Drudge Paradox: My NEW Taki’s piece
  • David Cole: What “hood pranks” reveal about the “collapsing” black “community”David Cole: What “hood pranks” reveal about the “collapsing” black “community”
  • NEW time, date, location for Toronto JDL protest against ‘Sea Hitler’ Gaza BoatNEW time, date, location for Toronto JDL protest against ‘Sea Hitler’ Gaza Boat
  • Ann Coulter: Las Vegas Massacre—The Story Is Coming ApartAnn Coulter: Las Vegas Massacre—The Story Is Coming Apart

Filed Under: conservative blog

« Ten bucks says Adam Lanza was ‘allergic’ to peanuts, too
‘They jumped out of their seats and ran toward the sound of the gunfire’ »
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Archives

Copyright © 2022 · Magazine Pro Theme On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in