5 Feet of Fury

Tedious “not all Muslims are terrorists” trope has “limited value”

Robert Spencer writes:

That not all Muslims are on board with the Islamic supremacist program is simply a fact, but it does not follow from that fact that there is any significant body of Muslims who are actively or seriously opposing the jihadists and Islamic supremacists. There are a few courageous individuals here and there, but as I have pointed out many times using Ibn Warraq’s phrase, while there are moderate Muslims, there is no moderate Islam.

And while some people are cultural and nominal Muslims who are ignorant of and/or indifferent to the jihad imperative, it cannot be assumed (as many Western government and law enforcement officials assume) that any given peaceful Muslim opposes the jihad simply by virtue of the fact that he is not actively engaged in violence or participating in plotting in a violent jihad group.

Moreover, when Muslims in America get angrier at me for discussing how other Muslims are using Islam to justify and spread an expansionist, totalitarian, and discriminatory ideology, than they do against those Muslims, it does not inspire confidence.

In fact, it should make every non-Muslim who witnesses it wonder at their misplaced priorities, and at just how insincere are their protestations of moderation.

(…)

I told him that I too was often singled out for extra searches in airports (…) I told him I didn’t mind any of this, since I loved America and knew about threat we were all facing, and so didn’t mind putting up with inconvenience for the sake of national security, knowing that if I wasn’t doing anything wrong, it would all come out all right in the end anyway.

But of course if one doesn’t hold in high regard the safety of innocent Americans, and would rather use the alleged mistreatment of Muslims in the war on terror as a means to halt those anti-terror efforts, one would not be interested in putting up with such inconveniences. Is that really the impression that this young man intended to leave with me and with the rest of the audience Friday night?